Saturday morning came in gray and raw, with low clouds over the river flats.
The night before, Dan had left the shop at 4:30 PM, because Jenny had asked him at breakfast if he would take her to the tree lighting downtown. He had said yes before he remembered there was no one at the office to ask. They hadn’t gone since Cal was small enough to ride on his shoulders. For thirty years of Decembers there had always been a call, or a close, or a deck to finish.
So they had stood on Main Street in the cold with three hundred other people, holding paper cups of cocoa from the church table, while the high school choir sang a little off-key and somebody’s toddler cried for Santa. When the big fir in front of the old bank lit up at 5:00 PM, Jenny slipped her gloved hand into his coat pocket beside his, the way she used to when they were dating. Dan’s phone stayed in the truck. He did not think about it once.
On the drive home she had hummed along with the radio, and he had almost told her everything.
At 7:15 AM Dan was standing by the kitchen door with his coat on and his hand on the knob.
Jenny came out of the laundry room with a basket of folded towels braced against her hip. She stopped when she saw him in his coat.
“They have you working Saturdays now?” she asked.
The lie sat right on Dan’s tongue: Year-end audit prep, just a half day. He had used it a hundred times.
He looked at Jenny’s face. There were fine lines around her eyes that he had earned for her, and a smudge of bleach on the cuff of her cardigan.
“I’m helping a guy down on Mill Street build a cradle,” Dan said. “White oak. Hand tools.”
Jenny kept the laundry basket against her hip. For a moment she didn’t move at all.
“I put the tin of Bag Balm in your coat pocket,” she said. “Don’t forget to eat at noon.”
On the drive down the hill, the town had its Christmas up in the daylight. Colored bulbs ran along the porch rails on the river road. Somebody had hung a wreath the size of a tractor tire on the volunteer fire hall. And in the side lot of the hardware store on Second Street stood the same plywood Santa and reindeer that had been there every December since Cal was in grade school, the paint worn down to bare wood where generations of kids had climbed on Rudolph.
When Dan walked into the shop at 8:00 AM, the light through the tall multi-pane windows was the color of pewter. Joe had the two wide planks for the cradle’s headboard and footboard panels laid out across the horses.
“Plane the faces clean so we can match the grain,” Joe said, heading out the back door toward the woodshed. “I need to bring in dry birch for the steam box.”
Dan locked the first wide board into the tail-vise and took up the heavy iron jack plane. On the third pass, as the blade skimmed a curl of oxidized gray wood off the center of the plank, the iron chattered with a hollow, papery tick-tick that sounded wrong for solid oak.
Dan stopped. He leaned down and smelled the fresh cut. Beneath the sweet, buttery tang of white oak was a faint, sour trace of wet cellar.
He tapped the center of the board with his knuckle. Solid on the left. Solid on the right. Dead and hollow in the middle.
When Joe kicked the back door open with an armload of birch, Dan had the chalk in his hand and had drawn a six-inch oval around the center of the pristine-looking plank.
“Honeycomb check,” Dan said, pointing at the mark. “Whoever kilned this or stacked the butt log let the outside dry too fast while the core was still wet. It looks whole on the surface, but the inside pulled itself apart. If we cut the headboard out of this, it’ll collapse the first time somebody leans on it.”
Joe dumped the birch into the box by the stove, walked over, and tapped the chalk circle.
Then he looked at Dan and smiled, a real, wide smile that showed his teeth through the dark beard.
“Thirty-one years of looking for what’s wrong,” Joe said, clapping a heavy hand on Dan’s shoulder. “Told you I needed a second pair of eyes.”